Article · The Hidden Work of Leadership

The Expert's Paradox: Why the Skills That Made You Excellent Aren't the Ones Leadership Asks For

The skills that make someone an excellent practitioner (precision, solving problems yourself, being right) are real, but they aren't the whole job of leading. Leadership also asks for influence, developing others and judgment with incomplete information. These are learnable, and they add to expertise rather than replace it.

Both: the strongest specialiston their teamGradually handed responsibilityfor new hires and junior staffStepped into a formal leadership roleLearned new ways of showing up, and thrivedKept leaning on individual-contributor skills, and struggled

Leading is its own skill. It’s a practice, a set of behaviours, a way of being.

Are you already leading?

If you’re a practice owner, a senior specialist or the person everyone brings problems to, you’re already leading, whether or not you chose to. The only question is whether you’re doing it by default or by design.

What does leadership ask for that expertise doesn’t?

What made you an excellent practitionerWhat leadership also asks for
Precision and control over the variablesandInfluence over people you can’t control
Solving the problem yourselfandDeveloping others to solve it
Immediate, visible resultsandSlow, indirect results through others
Being rightandBeing clear, consistent and trusted
Individual expertiseandCollective performance
Certainty before actingandJudgment with incomplete information

Read each row as “and”, not “instead of”. Your expertise still matters. It just isn’t the whole job.

Does this happen in other fields?

It happens to experts everywhere.

The top salesperson

Across 214 firms, the best salespeople were the most likely to be promoted, yet tended to be weaker managers.

Top sellerpromotedWeaker team results

Benson, Li and Shue, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2019

The great player

Wayne Gretzky coached the Coyotes for four seasons and never made the playoffs. Many of the best coaches were ordinary players.

Google’s best managers

When Google studied what its best managers actually did, it found eight key behaviours. Technical expertise ranked last.

8th: Technical expertise

Google’s Project Oxygen, reported in The New York Times, 2011

What do the best managers actually do?

Google’s Project Oxygen found that what set its best managers apart was mostly about people (Garvin, Harvard Business Review, 2013). Grouped into four:

  • Developing people: coaches, and gives people room to grow instead of micromanaging
  • Caring: shows real interest in each person’s success and wellbeing
  • Communicating: listens, and shares what people need to know
  • Direction: sets a clear vision and keeps the team focused on results

Think of the best leader you ever worked under. What did they actually do? Most people’s answers land on the same four things.

Is leading the same as managing?

Not quite. It helps to see them as two continuums rather than two boxes.

HighLeadershipLow

Both

Direction and working systems

Manages without leading

The schedule runs, but nobody would follow you anywhere

Leads without authority

The senior team member everyone takes their cues from

Neither

Things run on habit

LowManagementHigh

Management

Makes systems work

Schedules, protocols, budgets

Leadership

People and direction

Trust, motivation, standards, change

* There’s a time and place to be in each corner.

Low management High management
High leadership Leads without authority: the senior team member everyone takes their cues from Both: direction and working systems
Low leadership Neither: things run on habit Manages without leading: the schedule runs, but nobody would follow you anywhere

There’s a time and place for each corner. Under load, most of us drift toward the bottom row: fewer conversations, more firefighting. The people side is usually the first thing to slip.

Where do I start?

With yourself. Leading is its own skill: a practice, a set of behaviours, a way of being. The first step is seeing how you currently show up.

Frequently asked questions

Why do top performers sometimes struggle as leaders?

Because the skills that earned the promotion are about individual results, while leadership is about results through others. A study across 214 firms found the best salespeople were the most likely to be promoted, yet tended to be weaker managers (Benson, Li and Shue, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2019).

What is the difference between leadership and management?

Management makes systems work: schedules, protocols, budgets. Leadership is about people and direction: trust, motivation, standards, change. The distinction is often credited to John Kotter. You can manage without leading, and lead without authority.

← All articles & resources

Interested in coaching or a collaboration?

Let me know what brought you here and how I can help.

Contact me